ICMM Congress 2024: Maritime Museums and Underwater Archaeology

Value of the Information & Strength of the Argument

The session provides substantial value by demonstrating how maritime archaeological collections can be repurposed to address broader contemporary issues like climate change and ocean literacy. Each speaker presents a well-structured argument with concrete examples. Garry Momber argues convincingly that shipwrecks are not just historical objects but also function as scientific datum points for understanding seabed changes, using specific instances like the Bouldnor Cliff site. Catherine Green’s case study effectively illustrates the complexities of integrating private collections into public museums, covering legal, ethical, and practical considerations. The argumentation is strengthened by the inclusion of video footage and artifact examples. The presentations are persuasive in advocating for a paradigm shift in maritime heritage management, from object-centric to ecosystem-centric approaches.

Scientific Rigor, Source Quality, Title Accuracy

The scientific rigor is generally high, as the speakers are experienced professionals referencing their own institutional projects and recognised legislation such as the Abandoned Shipwreck Act (1987). However, the presentations are based on experiential knowledge rather than peer-reviewed publications, and specific data sources are not explicitly cited beyond institutional experience. The title of the session accurately reflects its content, covering maritime museums and underwater archaeology comprehensively. The discussion is grounded in real-world case studies, lending credibility. There are no external links provided in the description, so the sources are primarily the speakers’ professional testimonies.

Title accurately describes the session content on maritime museums and underwater archaeology.

8/10

Talks from recognised professionals in maritime archaeology and museum practice, presenting case studies and institutional experiences with clear methodologies.

Markers derived by PSI from the transcript: the creator did not define chapters.

• 00:00Welcome and session introduction by Fred Hocker.
• 02:00Garry Momber begins his talk on maritime archaeology and ocean literacy.
• 17:00Catherine Green presents on bridging museums and shipwreck artifact salvagers in Wisconsin.
• 32:00McAllie Givens and Rachel Recuero present on museum archaeology at The Mariners' Museum.
• 47:00Group discussion begins.

• Maritime Archaeology Trust — Mentioned by Garry Momber as his organisation.
• Wisconsin Maritime Museum — Catherine Green's case study institution.
• The Mariners' Museum & Park — Presented by McAllie Givens and Rachel Recuero.
• National Maritime Historical Society — Publisher of Sea History magazine, mentioned by Catherine Green.